Once hailed as the Dallas Cowboys’ “secret weapon,” running back Tony Pollard now finds himself in uncertain territory as training camp for the 2025 NFL season kicks off. With questions surrounding his production and the team’s evolving offensive identity, Pollard is reportedly at risk of being dropped from the starting lineup — a dramatic shift for a player who was once seen as the future of the Cowboys’ backfield.
From Breakout Star to Uncertain Future
Tony Pollard made headlines in previous seasons with his explosive playmaking ability and remarkable efficiency. In 2022 and 2023, he was considered one of the most dynamic backs in the league, averaging over 5 yards per carry and serving as a perfect complement—and eventual replacement—for Ezekiel Elliott.
However, 2024 told a different story. After signing a one-year deal under the franchise tag and taking over full-time duties, Pollard struggled to meet expectations. His yards per carry dropped, and he failed to deliver in crucial moments, particularly in short-yardage and red zone situations.
According to multiple reports from within the Cowboys’ camp, the coaching staff has grown concerned with Pollard’s lack of consistency and inability to dominate as a feature back. What was once seen as a strength—his speed and elusiveness—appeared diminished after dealing with injuries and a heavier workload.
Cowboys’ New Backfield Competition
As the 2025 season approaches, the Cowboys are clearly making moves to bolster the competition in their running back room. Rookie standout Malik Benson and free agent signing Javonte Williams have both impressed early in minicamp and are pushing for bigger roles in Mike McCarthy’s offense.
Javonte Williams, formerly of the Denver Broncos, is coming off a resurgent year after recovering from a major knee injury. His powerful running style and pass protection capabilities offer something Pollard has struggled with when facing elite defenses.
Meanwhile, Malik Benson, a versatile back with breakaway speed, has earned praise from Cowboys coaches for his vision, hands, and work ethic. According to sources close to the team, the coaching staff is already experimenting with lineups that feature Benson and Williams ahead of Pollard.
Pollard’s Role in Jeopardy?
With this level of competition, Tony Pollard’s role in the 2025 Cowboys offense is far from guaranteed. While he still brings valuable experience and flashes of explosive talent, the coaching staff appears focused on building a more balanced, power-oriented run game — potentially leaving Pollard without a clear fit.
NFL analyst James Palmer recently stated, “Tony Pollard was at his best when defenses underestimated him. Now that he’s the focal point, he’s being exposed in ways we didn’t see before.”
It’s a sentiment echoed by fans and insiders alike. While Pollard remains a fan favorite and a locker room leader, his future with the team could depend heavily on his performance during training camp and preseason.
What’s Next for Pollard?
Tony Pollard’s journey with the Cowboys isn’t over yet — but it’s at a crossroads. The 2025 season may very well determine whether he remains a key piece of the Cowboys’ long-term plans or becomes a free agent seeking a fresh start elsewhere.
If Pollard can rediscover his early-career explosiveness and adjust to a rotational role, he still has the tools to be a difference-maker. But if he fails to separate himself from the rising talent behind him, the Cowboys may have no choice but to move on.
Conclusion
Tony Pollard’s decline from “secret weapon” to possible backup illustrates the unforgiving nature of the NFL. For the Cowboys, success in 2025 will require tough decisions — and Pollard’s place on the roster is one of the most intriguing storylines to watch. As training camp unfolds, all eyes will be on whether he can rise to the challenge or fade into the background.
